Measuring Peace in Northern Ireland
February 6 2012: Is peace in Northern Ireland stable, or do we face merely a temporary break from large-scale violence? Northern Ireland's relative political stability and the Queen's symbolic first visit to the country in May 2011 are important parts of the peace process. However, violence and tensions among the population continue. New initiatives to measure Northern Ireland's peace process are needed. Paul Nolan of Nothern Ireland Peace Monitoring Survey, explains how they will assess the progress of the peace process.
At the end of June 2011 the international media returned to Northern Ireland to report on a story very different from those that made their headlines during the 30 year period known euphemistically as the ‘Troubles’. This time the story concerned the quite remarkable success of three local golfers: Graeme McDowell, Rory McIlroy and Darren Clarke. Between them they scooped the British Open and the US Open. Twice.
Their achievement is impressive for a region which has barely any history of successful sportsmen. Rory McIlroy, who had snatched the US Open from the Americans just one year after his fellow-countryman Graeme McDowell had pulled the same trick, made particularly good copy, being a fresh faced, curly-headed Irish lad with a natural easy charm.
This sort of violence was supposed to be over. The peace settlement was signed in 1998, already thirteen years ago. Tellingly, this accord is known by two names: Catholics tend to call it the Good Friday Agreement while Protestants choose to shed its religious connotation and call it simply the Belfast Agreement. The process of implementing the Agreement (the simplest label) over the past 13 years has been zigzag and unsteady, but a new beginning came in May 2007 with the restoration of the devolved powers that had been suspended because of the years of political wrangling. When that parliament completed its mandate in May 2011 it was the first NI parliament to stay the course for 40 years.
“The week when Britain and Ireland grew up”
The elections which followed were conducted in reasonable good humour and with the confidence that this parliament will also serve it its full term. It was in the light of such success that the British monarch, Queen Elizabeth, chose to make her first ever visit to Dublin. The visit, seen to be of huge symbolic importance, was an unqualified success. In the briefings before it began the Department of Foreign Affairs said that 1,200 journalists and 120 photographers had been given accreditation. Towards the end of the four day stay, they were asking historians to bring the additional depth of perspective the occasion seemed to demand. The visit was seen not just as the ceremonial moment could act as the full stop to mark the end of the Northern Ireland peace process, but as the symbolic end of 800 years of enmity between Britain and Ireland. The respected Irish Times columnist Fintan O’Toole headed an article on 22 May ‘The Week When Britain and Ireland grew up‘.
Why then were they rioting on the streets of Belfast one month later? And which image presents the more significant reality – the Queen shaking hands for the first time with the President of Ireland, or the rioters hurling the petrol bombs? The Northern Ireland peace process in its current phase can be difficult to read. At times it appears to be moving forward, at other times it seems to be going backwards. Most confusingly it can sometimes appear to be doing both at once, like those optical illusion drawings by Escher where the people who are ascending the staircase appear, mysteriously, to be descending at the same time.
In order to get a better fix on the movements of the peace process a new project has been launched, under the title of the Northern Ireland Peace Monitoring Survey. The sponsors of the project are the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, an English charity with a strong tradition of social research, its sister organisation, the Joseph Rowntree Charitable Trust, which has invested heavily in peacebuilding in Northern Ireland, and thirdly, the Community Relations Council which since 1990 has been the key agency in cross-community work in Northern Ireland. The aim of the project is to issue an annual state-of-the-nation style report on the peace process. This will involve creating an indicator framework that will not only track political violence but also social cohesion, equality, and political progress. This type of deep analysis may help provide an understanding of whether the Agreement has delivered a permanent peace, or simply a generational truce in a centuries-old conflict. The first report will be issued in early 2012.
All enquiries to: firstname.lastname@example.org
More from the blog
Huge numbers of people have fled the Syrian conflict. Adam Leake discusses some of the issues in Jordan, where many of them have arrived. Read more »